7 replies to this topic

[britishseapowerman]

I'm headed to Guadalupe in August on the Nautilus Explorer and I am looking for any input anyone has on the setup to shoot the sharks from the cages. I have the T2i and 2 lens set ups I plan on using:

1) the Tokina 10-17mm behind the S&S NX Dome Port
2) the Canon 17-40mm behind the S&S NX Dome Port plus the 40mm Port Extension

Having researched this in depth I am concerned that I may have made a bad decision with the 17-40mm and perhaps should have went for the 10-22mm (but its not too late to correct the mistake!). I understand there will be no 'right' setup 100% of the time - but I chose this setup as I think it will give me a good mix of shots of the sharks. Any input anyone has on shooting sharks from cages would be appreciated - especially in the good viz conditions at guadalupe. Should I bite the bullet and get the 10-22mm as well????

Thanks,

[Steve Douglas]

Try to make sure that anyone who is in the cage with you is not bouncing around in excitement. A bouncing cage is a pain. Since they have 3 cages in the water, I would put myself in a far corner spot so other shooters do not get in the way of my imaging. Wear a drysuit, hood and gloves. August is a bit early for Whites at Guadalupe but you should have a good time. Unfortunately, no bacon with your eggs aboard the NE. The vis is usually pretty decent there but I do not know whether the NE has started to chum again. They stopped for awhile which brought the whites going from left to right and right to left but not coming into you head first which is always a better shot imo.
Steve

[gina]

Having researched this in depth I am concerned that I may have made a bad decision with the 17-40mm and perhaps should have went for the 10-22mm (but its not too late to correct the mistake!). I understand there will be no 'right' setup 100% of the time - but I chose this setup as I think it will give me a good mix of shots of the sharks. Any input anyone has on shooting sharks from cages would be appreciated - especially in the good viz conditions at guadalupe. Should I bite the bullet and get the 10-22mm as well????

When I was at Guadalupe I shot with a 5D (full-frame sensor) and a 16-35mm lens. It was rare that the animals were so close that I couldn't frame the shots well. When I was down 30 feet in the submersible cage the sharks were often too far away to shoot with the 16-35. All that being said, if I were to do it again I would shoot with my 16-35, but I would also bring my 15mm fisheye just for a different style of shot.

Here are my photos so you can get an idea of how that lens was shooting out there: (but please note that I was new to u/w photography at the time and those shots aren't great).

-Gina

[britishseapowerman]

When I was at Guadalupe I shot with a 5D (full-frame sensor) and a 16-35mm lens. It was rare that the animals were so close that I couldn't frame the shots well. When I was down 30 feet in the submersible cage the sharks were often too far away to shoot with the 16-35. All that being said, if I were to do it again I would shoot with my 16-35, but I would also bring my 15mm fisheye just for a different style of shot.

Here are my photos so you can get an idea of how that lens was shooting out there: (but please note that I was new to u/w photography at the time and those shots aren't great).

-Gina

Thanks - Gina - that's what I hoped to hear:) Great shots!

[philsokol]

When I was there a couple years ago, I shot the 10-17 on my 40D and it was too wide for 90% of the shots. If I were going back today, I'd bring my Sigma 17-70 for the extra reach, so I think your 17-40 should be perfect.

Have a great trip!

Phil

[haring]

I'm headed to Guadalupe in August on the Nautilus Explorer and I am looking for any input anyone has on the setup to shoot the sharks from the cages. I have the T2i and 2 lens set ups I plan on using:

1) the Tokina 10-17mm behind the S&S NX Dome Port
2) the Canon 17-40mm behind the S&S NX Dome Port plus the 40mm Port Extension

Having researched this in depth I am concerned that I may have made a bad decision with the 17-40mm and perhaps should have went for the 10-22mm (but its not too late to correct the mistake!). I understand there will be no 'right' setup 100% of the time - but I chose this setup as I think it will give me a good mix of shots of the sharks. Any input anyone has on shooting sharks from cages would be appreciated - especially in the good viz conditions at guadalupe. Should I bite the bullet and get the 10-22mm as well????

Thanks,

Please share your photos when you are back!!!

[Steve Douglas]

When I was there a couple years ago, I shot the 10-17 on my 40D and it was too wide for 90% of the shots. If I were going back today, I'd bring my Sigma 17-70 for the extra reach, so I think your 17-40 should be perfect.

Have a great trip!

Phil

Would like to see some examples of the shots you took with the 10-17. Since they come in pretty close, surprised that the 10-17 was too wide. It's been awhile since I've been there and didn't use a 10-17 the last time so would love to see some of your examples.
Steve