I can not figure out, why you need different lubricants for all your o-rings, when only one can do the job.
It is very important to use the proper lubricant for the type of o-ring you have. The wrong lubricant will swell or dry out the elastomer and the o-ring might not seal anymore. Swelling is not that bad usually, though it will weaken the material. Drying out the o-ring will make them brittle like an old rubber band.