Jump to content
photodouglas

Lightroom Options & Suggestions

Recommended Posts

Hi - I'm current using a version of Lightroom 5 which has been sufficient in the past but is now seems to be on the way out.  So I'm considering the switch to Adobe's subscription based Lightroom CC.  Has anyone else experienced such a change?  If so, I'd welcome your thoughts, feedback, suggestions and comments on how it worked out for you.  Thanks!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi!

This is completely my personal opinion based on my own needs and situation.

I was using Lightroom 6 in my previous computer. I bought a license for it, but it was not a subscription, I could use it till the end of time if I wanted -- and if my computer allowed.

My computer started to show aging issues, so I upgraded, but I couldn't transfer Lightroom 6 to the new computer. Adobe doesn't have the installers in their website, and I didn't want to dig into obscure websites looking for installers. So I went with the new subscription based offering.

My feelings? I don't like that I don't own the software anymore. As soon as I stop paying the monthly fee I won't be able to use it. Over a lifetime of use I will end up paying way much more now. Plus, if you update to the new version, your library will be updated to a new version that it's not backwards compatible, so you are pretty much stuck with the new version if you start editing photos with it. I'm sure that this new subscription model is great for Adobe, but I don't like it.

Yes, I will always have the latest version, but I don't think that for what I do, how I use Lightroom, the move from Lightroom 6, which I owned, to the subscription based Lightroom, which now I'm just renting, wasn't worth it. I was forced to do it, but I would have happily stayed with Lightroom 6 if I could have.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

About a year ago, I  moved from LR6 to the subscription package. I read a few articles about the process and went ahead with fingers crossed. Just followed the Adobe prompts on screen and with a couple of minor hangups, it all loaded smoothly. It has all worked well since with the exception of the upgrades that come out periodically. Some have been a real PITA with multiple attempts to download them but suddenly they load without me altering anything. The last upgrades however went smoothly. Good luck.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I upgraded about half a year ago. I also don't like the subscription model, but I really wanted to use LR on my iPad. Editing and culling while I'm still on a trip (or on the plane back) means that instead of spending hours on the computer after the holidays, I can show my pictures to friends and family immediately. It's also much nicer when sharing on the internet. Before I used LR6 (which was enough for everything else and worked very well), but I had to use Affinity Photo on the go, which is a great photoshop replacement but not very quick for editing Rawfiles. 

Btw, the LR6 installer is still on Adobes Website, but it is incredibly well hidden. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The upgrade will work fine most likely,  it's a matter of whether you want to subscribe or not.  I think for most amatuers the subscription thing is a giant con, they basically hold you to ransom as the upgrades they offer are really not worth it.   They are masters of hiding stuff on their website as well.  Whether you can keep using it depends in some part of your operating system.  On Mac they have made changes making it difficult to install on the newer OS, On Windows, Windows 10 seems to install lightroom 6 and CS6 just fine still

There are alternatives out there to consider including Capture one Pro and affinity photo.  I bought Capture one pro rather than upgrade to PS CC when I bought my most recent camera - it does a great job of raw conversion.  I still finish off in PS, but what comes out of C1 Pro is quite good and I could do more there, but still use PS as the workflow is more familiar.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The thing with Capture one Pro is that it is so expensive, that the LR subscription doesn't seem so bad. Yes, you will own the software and you can decide when to upgrade, but I upgraded from 4 to 5 to 6 in a relatively short timeframe and then stuck with them because I didn't want to go subscription. It is true though that worthwhile new features have been quite rare since LR CC came out. I think it's really only the dehaze and detail slider + LR mobile.

There are however a few features that no other software currently has. And that is the built in HDR and Pano mode directly from RAW and into a new RAW Format. I use it all the time for my landscape images.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The last version of Lightroom classic perpetual is the 6.14

Inside the software that are camera RAW processors and profiles so if you have a camera that was not supported by this release you may still try adobe camera RAW and import but it will be sub-optimal.

Full list here

https://helpx.adobe.com/camera-raw/kb/camera-raw-plug-supported-cameras.html?red=a

Furthermore most of the usefulness of lightroom comes from metadata editing and library management which is lost if you migrate elsewhere

So when you will get a camera not supported by the last perpetual license you will be pretty much forced into an upgrade unless you want to rework your library

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have LR 6.14, which was the last version with an educational discount. It does not support my latest camera, the Olympus TG-6.

I downloaded the latest Adobe DNG converter and use that to create files that LR 6.14 can read. It's not that difficult a change to my editing work flow.

I tried one other photo edit program, but the upgrade policy & pricing was too ludicrous to believe, so I shelved it permanently.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I had LR 5 for a long time but any time I had issues with my ageing Mac, it got harder and harder to re-load. Bought a LR subscription and never looked back. Yup you're paying a lot over a lifetime but if u use it professionally, or even as a serious amateur, it's worth it.

If you want to own software outright, look at Luminar 4. I also have and use this. It does pretty much everything LR does with a sprinkling of PS thrown in too. Very intuitive. Basically the same layout and features of LR (don't know how they got away with it TBH as to me it's just a copy of LR with a few extra artificial intelligence features added). That aside, it is amazing software. Yes, they ask you to pay for new features, but at the level Luminar4 is now at, I cannot imagine anything else you would need to add.

Sent from my CLT-L29 using Tapatalk

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was forced to update to the CC subscription due to my computer's operating system no longer supporting the version of Lightroom that I owned. 

Photography is purely a hobby for me, and I try not to think about the absurd amount of money that I will be spending on this product over the years for something that doesn't make me any money. That being said, I definitely can afford the $10/month, and it does have some neat new features as others have mentioned. I've had some problems with newly released updates to Lightroom Classic crashing on newly released operating systems (OS X), but it's generally fixed within a reasonable timeframe. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

A bit late to the party here, but I'd like to chip in as well.

I've been using LR since 2011 and I'm on the subscription since fairly soon after it started. I, too, have my qualms about the subscription model. The software itself however has, IMO, improved immensely since version 6. This I hold to be true both for useful features and speed optimizations. Even were version 6 compatible with all new cameras I wouldn't want to go back to that. For me the improvements are worth the subscription fee.

This is of course a case of YMMV. If I used LR twice a year I would already have switched to some other software. As a regular user I have chosen to grudgingly accept the subscription model.

(What I oppose in the subscription model is not the cost, which is roughly equal to keep upgrading the program before it became a subscription. It's the loss of functionality if I stop paying.)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are other options, some are free or inexpensive. Darktable appears to be quite nice (learning curve if you are using LR/PS). Luminar is also quite good and only $89.  For me though the subscription model is not a big issue, I just skip Starbucks once a week and am about even. 

Bill

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, bvanant said:

There are other options, some are free or inexpensive. Darktable appears to be quite nice (learning curve if you are using LR/PS). Luminar is also quite good and only $89.  For me though the subscription model is not a big issue, I just skip Starbucks once a week and am about even. 

Bill

From the testing that I have done with other software (Darktable, Rawtherapy, Nikon Capture), none come close to matching Adobe Camera Raw (or Lightroom) to correct white balance of underwater pictures made in ambiant light.

With Camera Raw, I can recover color from pictures taken quite deep, with a workflow which can be mostly automated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Interesting.

I figure the time and effort I have put into learning LR over many years (since 1.0,  having the subscription with its updates etc, is well worth it. And, as bavanat points out, it's the cost of a Starbucks a month.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sponsors

Advertisements



×
×
  • Create New...